Three pieces into this series, we've covered what the various alternatives are, how people get access to private companies, and what happened this spring when a lot of investors tried to get their money back at once.
Which leaves the question everyone actually wants answered. Should I own any of this, and if so, how much?
The answer doesn't start with the investment. It starts with your calendar.
First, name the job
Every position in a portfolio should be doing work. Alternatives can do three kinds, and they're distinct enough that it's worth deciding which one you're hiring for before you look at a single fund.
Diversification
Owning something that doesn't move in lockstep with your stocks. Infrastructure, real assets, and certain hedge fund strategies are typically hired for this. One caution worth carrying: when an asset is appraised quarterly rather than priced daily, its correlation to public markets looks lower than it truly is. Some of that smoothness is measurement, not diversification.
Income
Cash flow above what public bonds pay. Private credit is the usual tool. You're being compensated for credit risk and for restricted access to your money, and the second part is easy to underweight when the distribution rate is printed in large type.
Access
Exposure to companies that stay private for decades. Private equity and venture strategies do this, along with public funds holding a sleeve of private positions. This is the longest-horizon job of the three.
If you can't name which of those three a position is being hired for, that's the finding. Don't buy it yet.
Then build the liquidity budget
This is the part that does the real work, and almost nobody does it before they're pitched rather than after.
Divide your money by when you'll need it. Not by account type, not by asset class. By calendar.
A Liquidity Budget
Sort by when the money gets spent, then decide what can be restricted.
Zero to two years
Living expenses, the tax bill, the new roof, the health event nobody scheduled. This money exists to be available on short notice.
No illiquid assets. None.
Two to ten years
The engine of the plan. It needs to be rebalanced, drawn from, and adjusted as circumstances change, which requires the ability to sell things when you decide to rather than when a window opens.
Liquid, with rare exceptions
Ten years and beyond
Money for late retirement, for heirs, or for purposes that genuinely have no near-term claim on it. This is the only tier where a lockup costs you nothing you were going to use.
Where illiquidity belongs
And even here, not all of it.The illiquid sleeve should be a portion of your longest-dated money, not the whole of it.
Run that exercise honestly and the sizing question tends to answer itself. For most households, the amount of capital with a genuine ten-year-plus horizon and no competing claim is a good deal smaller than the number a pitch deck assumes.
The sizing test
Once you have a candidate amount, one question tells you whether it's right.
Could you leave this alone through the worst stretch you can picture?
Public markets are where you'd rebalance and raise cash. If a large share of your portfolio can't be sold, the liquid part carries all of that burden alone.
The most common reason people need money sooner than planned. Restricted capital doesn't care about your reasons.
Assume the redemption limit applies when you want out, because that's precisely when everyone else wants out too.
If the answer to all three is yes, the size is probably reasonable. If any answer is no, the position is too large regardless of how attractive the investment looks.
Four mistakes worth avoiding
Buying the whole allocation in one year.
Private funds are heavily influenced by when they invest. Committing across several years rather than all at once spreads that timing risk, the same way you'd never put an entire bond allocation into a single maturity date.
Counting a semi-liquid fund as part of your reserves.
Quarterly redemption is a feature, not a guarantee. Reserves live in things that settle in days.
Ignoring how the fees stack.
There is often a fee at the fund, sometimes a fee on top of the fund, and costs embedded in the structure itself. The illiquidity premium is real, but it gets spent before it reaches you if the layers are deep enough.
Mistaking a smooth line for a safe one.
Quarterly appraisals produce statements that look calmer than daily pricing. The underlying risk didn't change. Only the reporting frequency did.
How we think about it
Portfolio construction at our firm runs on written rules rather than instinct. Every model is built from a documented set of construction standards, measured against a custom benchmark built to mirror its intended structure, and rebalanced on a defined schedule rather than a hunch. Every rule and every change is reviewed and approved before it's implemented, and the reasoning gets recorded so it can be revisited later.
The models are a foundation, not a boundary. Depending on your goals, tax situation, and preferences, a portfolio may draw on them, complement them, or be tailored in ways specific to you.
Today those models are built with liquid, transparent, daily-priced investments. That's a deliberate choice. Most households reach their goals without restricted capital, and complexity that doesn't earn its place is just cost.
We continue to evaluate where alternatives could contribute something a liquid portfolio can't, particularly for households whose balance sheet and time horizon can genuinely support illiquidity. If and when we bring them in, it will go through the same process as everything else: a defined role, a benchmark, a documented rule for how much, and a clear answer to the question this whole series has been circling. What are we giving up, and what are we getting for it?
The conversation worth having
If you're holding something in this space and aren't certain what you agreed to, or you're being pitched something and want a second read before you commit, that's a straightforward conversation and a useful one. Bring the offering documents. The redemption terms and the fee schedule tell us most of what we need to know.
And if this is simply new territory you're curious about — you've been hearing the terms, you'd like to understand them, and you want to know whether any of it belongs in your plan — that's worth an hour too. We'll start with your situation rather than with a product, and you'll leave understanding the trade whether or not you ever make it.
Sometimes that conversation ends with the conclusion that your plan reaches its goals with liquid, transparent, low-cost investments and doesn't need improving. That's a legitimate outcome, and a common one.
Looking for More Financial Insights?
Browse our latest articles on retirement planning, investing, tax strategies, and more.
View All Articles